stress_von_mises Operator with nodal stress order of output

I am working on script that have to extract data - node ids, coordinates, displacement and Von misses stress to csv. As coordinates and displacement works fine, stress seems to be working differently, order of output is different - not sorted by node ids.
below is part of the code that is extracting stress.

 stress_von_mises = ops.result.stress_von_mises(data_sources=model)
    # Restrict scoping to named selection
    stress_von_mises.inputs.mesh_scoping.connect(nodal_scope)
    stress_von_mises.inputs.time_scoping.connect(LS)
    stress_von_mises.inputs.requested_location.connect('Nodal')
fields_stress=np.asmatrix(stress_von_mises.outputs.fields_container.get_data()[0].data)

While i am using above method first element of array is not a stress at first node that i am extracting from scoping with method as below.

node_ids=nodal_scope.ids

While i am using same methodology for displacement it works fine. I don't understand why this is happening with stress.

displacement = ops.result.displacement(data_sources=model)
    # Restrict scoping to named selection
    displacement.inputs.mesh_scoping.connect(nodal_scope)
    displacement.inputs.time_scoping.connect(LS)
fields_disp=np.asmatrix(displacement.outputs.fields_container.get_data()[0].data)

Do you know how i can retrieve the order that stress are written into the field ?

as the code need to be efficient i can't use extraction with for loop and extracting by one node at the time (get_entity_data_by_id for example)

Find more posts tagged with

Python

DPF

Accepted answers

All comments

Mike.Thompson

How do you know the “correct” order of the calculated values? Are you matching values with some other validated method?
If you have a reproducible case of the values not matching the order of the nodal scoping ids this should be filed as a defect.

kacper.J

so i know a nodes from node_ids=nodal_scope.ids i am using for displacement and data written from DPF match with result i am taking from APDL, but while i am taking the first data from stress field its not the same as in apdl for first node at node_ids=nodal_scope.ids

anyway i found a way to extract node ids directly from field container and it solved a problem in this way order of ids match with order of stress

stress_von_mises.outputs.fields_container()[0].scoping.ids[0]

Pernelle Marone-Hitz

Maybe this helps: https://discuss.ansys.com/discussion/comment/1370#Comment_1370?utm_source=community-search&utm_medium=organic-search&utm_term=rescope